mui thai or wushu stronger?

mui thai & wushu, which is stronger?

Results are only viewable after voting.

Status
Not open for further replies.
ConnorMcLeod said:
saw one TV program, the tyoe similar to myth buster, which uses science to analyse the different forms of martial arts. basically they use a modified crash test dummy to multiple sensors to measure force of impact, compression of rib cage, concussion, etc etc etc, when the dummy was punched, kicked , etc. think martial art was the less lethal one. But then, again, the martial art was demonstrated by a relatively small build asian while the other like karate was demonstrated by a big caucasian. anyway, unless the same person knows all forms of martial arts and do this test, otherwise it is not a good measurement.

same I think for Muay Thai vs Wushu. The 'art' is how well one can predict/counter the opponent's action. It is brain and brawn. unless the one fights him/herself, otherwise you are not observing purely the effectiveness of the martial arts. Maybe computer model (also like the one which builds robots to fight robot :) )
Click to expand...

May be you can take part in the match? you r Connor Mcleod from the clan McLeod, a HighLander.:bsmilie::bsmilie:
 

hazmee said:
If looks can kill, Steven Seagal's shiny jet black backcombed hair is enough to KO his opponents. I think neither Muay Thai or Wushu has established such a technique.
Click to expand...

Hey, He's one of few actor with actual 7th Dan Aikido martial arts background ok....
And to be the first non-asian to run an Aikido dojo in Japan must be tough.
I imagine like going Thailand to teach them Muay Thai, and thats like 30yrs ago, when the world isnt as open up.
 

Jean Claude van Dam would be very disappointed if he read this thread.
 

who will emerge the victor depends more on the fighter/practitioner than the school of martial art. But having said that, having a "rounded" martial arts education also helps. IMHO, a good rounded fighter needs to be competent in the external arts like punching (e.g. boxing), kicking(TKD), locking & throwing (e.g jujitsu), blocking, counter-attacking (e.g. how to reverse a lock/throw), and also using weapons. ALso he would need to be competent in the inner-kungfu (e.g.Taichi) and using inner-strength.
 

com300 said:
who will emerge the victor depends more on the fighter/practitioner than the school of martial art. But having said that, having a "rounded" martial arts education also helps. IMHO, a good rounded fighter needs to be competent in the external arts like punching (e.g. boxing), kicking(TKD), locking & throwing (e.g jujitsu), blocking, counter-attacking (e.g. how to reverse a lock/throw), and also using weapons. ALso he would need to be competent in the inner-kungfu (e.g.Taichi) and using inner-strength.
Click to expand...

Of course lah! u kiasu mention so many...lol:bsmilie:
Must also be competent in medicine, psychology, nutrition science.etc etc..:bsmilie:
 

Fiction:
A thin weak looking guy turns up, not claiming to be from any famous martial arts academy like Shaolin, Ermei, Wutang, etc..
He takes on the five Muay Thai guys and is thoroughly bashed up. He only manages to touch them weakly a few times each.
The MT guys win and celebrate their victory.
They hold press conferences and declare theirs is the best.
Then.. 10 days after the bout, they all die suddenly.
Western doctors cannot figure out how.
It is not poisoning.
There is no visible physical injury.
The thin weak looking guy cannot be found.
Returned to the mountainous forests.

Dim Mark.
点血道
 

Last edited:
The more powerful man is the weak skinny guy who
can put a light touch on the vital point of the human
body. This is another area of kungfu not known to
others as often as TKD, Boxing, etc.

Another area is the powerful force (internal power) that
can push you away without even touching you.
 

maxtheevil said:
i used to think that muay thai is better to chinese wu shu , san da.

but apparently, this is not so.

chinese wu shu, san da has evolved to effective counterattacks when faced with brutal direct muay thai style.

that said...

why would a post modern human get into a physical fight nowadays?

which is stronger,

in peaceful times, the right of the law is stronger

in chaotic times, the bullet is mightier.

in bed times? haha, up to individual preferences, some like opposite sex, some same sex, some from behind...
Click to expand...


best read :thumbsup:
 

If you see, there is no strongest martial arts in the world but strongest fighter.

Different Martial Arts suit different people. Make it short and sweet, the person is the weapon, the martial art is only an enhancement.
 

denniskee said:
just read from tuesday night paper, 5 mui thai masters challenging china wushu, shao lin turn down, er mei accept. match is on 19-12-09 at guang dong china, homeland of bruce lee.

stated as record :

1) one mui thai master lost to a wushu master in july 09 cause rule states cant use knee & elbow

2) china wushu master in 1921 lost to mui thai after receiving just 3 hits & another was killed in a match in 1924

there were no official records match between the 2 deciplines after 1924.

this is not a thread about moral issues of martial art, just pure and simple question, which do u think is stronger?
Click to expand...

As a MMA enthusiast friend would say to me, "Everyone has a game plan until getting punched in the face"... so I'd say it's really the person executing the art than the art itself.
 

forward said:
Another area is the powerful force (internal power) that
can push you away without even touching you.
Click to expand...

we had posted 2 clips on this, do take a look a few pages before.

Muay thai is totally no match for that. :thumbsup:
 

When I was a pro, WuShu was always better. My Dragon Punch (tm) makes me invulnerable the muay thai Tiger Upper Cut can still be hit on execution.
 

ricohflex said:
Fiction:
A thin weak looking guy turns up, not claiming to be from any famous martial arts academy like Shaolin, Ermei, Wutang, etc..
He takes on the five Muay Thai guys and is thoroughly bashed up. He only manages to touch them weakly a few times each.
The MT guys win and celebrate their victory.
They hold press conferences and declare theirs is the best.
Then.. 10 days after the bout, they all die suddenly.
Western doctors cannot figure out how.
It is not poisoning.
There is no visible physical injury.
The thin weak looking guy cannot be found.
Returned to the mountainous forests.

Dim Mark.
点血道
Click to expand...

Wah! Hokuto no Ken is the best!:thumbsup:
 

hazmee said:
Jean Claude van Dam would be very disappointed if he read this thread.
Click to expand...

ya, doing a split doesn't help to defeat an opponent at all :bsmilie:

forward said:
Another area is the powerful force (internal power) that
can push you away without even touching you.
Click to expand...

Body odor, bad breath and fart?
 

Last edited:
UandMe said:
we had posted 2 clips on this, do take a look a few pages before.

Muay thai is totally no match for that. :thumbsup:
Click to expand...

Unfortunately he 'retired' after that match, wonder if his students carried on his skill, else its lost forever...
 

Your mouth is stronger than any martial arts combined.
 

天下武功出少林
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top