d300s or d90 which is worth buying?


Perhaps I should make myself more clear...my sister wants to take over my D80, so I'm getting a new cam. My options are either the D90 or D300s. So in a way I gotta buy something, just what to buy is the question.

I'd be spending close to $4000 if I got the D300s plus a lens like the 16-85 or 18-200. For the same amount of money I could get a D90, 16-85 plus the 10.5mm fisheye which I like for the effects. The D300s is very tempting with the 51 AF points, weather sealing, faster fps but is it worth that extra cash or should I just go for D90 and add more lenses with the extra cash?

It is worth the money if you use the additional features.

My brother took over my D90, and I got a D300s to replace it. Why? I use a lot of non-cpu lenses, and the ability to meter is good to have. Also, I find I shoot a lot faster now with the D300s, especially with all the camera and custom menu settings memory banks I can store. No need to change setting by setting again. Just switch to a different bank and I am good to go.
 

Last edited:
How about if I don't have any non-CPU lenses? I started with digital and I don't have any of the film stuff.
 

It seems many people here do not have a clear understanding of the differences between the 2 cameras.

Having used both the D90 and D300s, let me set the record straight one more time.

Image quality comparison
D90 and D300s uses the same sensor. Image quality is almost the same. ISO performance is almost the same. D90 seems better but it is because it is a consumer model and tuned to have a slightly stronger NR. D300s is more of a professional model and it is tuned to retain more details. Yes this is true even at the RAW files level.


What D300s has that D90 doesn't
- D300s has ability to meter with Ai Ais lenses. You can use center weighted or stop metering by default. If you enter the info into "non-cpu lens info" you will be able to use Color matrix metering.
- Magnesium alloy body with weather sealing
- 7 FPS (slightly over 6FPS in real life). Can boost up to 8 FPS with grip and using D3's battery.)
- Mirror up shooting mode to reduce even more vibrations. Quiet shooting mode. Fast Continuous and Slow Continuous shooting mode.
- Faster and more accurate AF.
- Bigger magnesium alloy body.
- You can store sets of settings in D300s, calling them up at will
- Many more buttons for faster access
- Built in interval timer
- 100% viewfinder
- Dual memory card slots (CF and SDHC)
- 51 AF points (configurable to 11 or 9)
- A lot more info and options in Image review mode. When reviewing images, automatic face detection for checking focus on faces, RGB histograms, active focus point indication.. etc..

Downsides of D300s
- Significantly heavier
- Cannot use cheap wireless IR remote for D90. D300s requires you use the remote port located on the front of the body. More troublesome and remotes are more expensive.
- Camera is a lot more expensive.
- D300s' battery grip is a lot more expensive.
- D300s loses all the scene modes from the D90. If you choose D300s, you're on your own.

Should you get D90 or D300s (IMHO)

- If you do not shoot in extreme conditions (extreme cold, wet, jungle, snow, rain), go for D90.
- If you want to shoot a lot with old manual focus lenses (Ai, Ais), go for D300s.
- If you want lightweight, go for D90.
- If you shoot a lot of fast action, sports, or flying birds, go for D300s.
- If you are more of a casual shooter, with a few modern current day lenses, go for D90.

Do not make a buying decision on the two models based on image quality. Because image quality are almost identical. D300s's output is more tuned to the professional, whom are expected to do more PP. D90's output is sharper, with more NR, which is tuned more to the consumer, whom are more likely to just use the pictures out-of-cam. But if you do a lot of PP, you will realize that the output from D300s will be easier to work with, giving you more options. But really, the differences are really really very slight.

Just ask yourself, do you really need the additional features D300s offers?

And always remember the weight of the D300s is no joke. Hold it long enough in a model/wedding shoot and you may find your arms aching and your hands shaky.

D300s is bigger and better. But question to ask yourself, do you need all those bells and whistles? Are you even going to use those features?

HTH.

deltatango here something for you to read abt, and make ya decision,

Opinion here varies, some will say with the $4k budget, get d90 and good glass,
some will say and D300s and get what ever good glass u can get,(can still squeeze a 2nd hand 17-55 2.8 or brand new 16-85).

its all depend on you...:)
 

How about if I don't have any non-CPU lenses? I started with digital and I don't have any of the film stuff.

Then i will say D90 is gd enough for you for now should u dont require the speed and additional features :)
 

How about if I don't have any non-CPU lenses? I started with digital and I don't have any of the film stuff.

tango ... just like master guru dd123 said previously.
get the Ais Nikkor lens if one owned D300s.
check with him if you need any help on Ais lenses.
I think its cheeper getting non-cpu lenses.
You can even buy somethin else with tat extra cash.

just my 2 cents ... :)
 

tango ... just like master guru dd123 said previously.
get the Ais Nikkor lens if one owned D300s.
check with him if you need any help on Ais lenses.
I think its cheeper getting non-cpu lenses.
You can even buy somethin else with tat extra cash.

just my 2 cents ... :)

I am no guru. Please don't use that term. Thanks.

I have experience only with a few Ai, Ais lenses and most of them are fast primes. They are indeed cheaper. But you have to do manual focus. There are also several 3rd party lenses that at Ai Ais based and require MF, but are excellent in IQ: like Carl Zeiss and Voigtlander.
 

was thinking to start a thread asking whether go for D90 or D300s
now I guess I got the answer
 

IF for travelling Buy D90
If for Hobby buy D90
If don't lke heavy camera buy D90
D90 good buy now.
 

I am contemplating on the decision.
End up aiming at D300s.
Beside there is the jack for flash for studio use. (Line of work may require studio photography sometimes)
So.... Spend a bit to save some headaache later on.

:)
 

your headache will be more severe when you wan2 change to FX..... for some FX is like the final frontier.

Im a D90 user but im ok with the crop factor... the only complaint is when using it on Low light...
 

I have got D90 Months ago and tried my Friend's D300. D300 is heavier the D90. I rather spend extra money for Flash (SB-600), Good Tripod (Manfrotto 190XPROB+496CR2 or 488CR2) and may be some prime lenses and Cokin Filter system.
My D90 also survive Mount KK right up to the Low's Peak :cool:.
Any DSLR camera you get you must have UV Filter for your lenses to protect the front lenses.
 

would some technical data be of help in your decision? check it out: dxomark
 

How come D300S most places out of stock? is a new model coming?
 

How come D300S most places out of stock? is a new model coming?

D300s replacement rumored to come in 2011.

What are the most places you mean?

Likely no stock due to high demand and retailers don't keep a lot of stock from what I know. It's a hot selling dSLR. I guess they are pretty controlled by their regional sales requirement.
 

The one that's really out of stock is D700..
 

I have got D90 Months ago and tried my Friend's D300. D300 is heavier the D90. I rather spend extra money for Flash (SB-600), Good Tripod (Manfrotto 190XPROB+496CR2 or 488CR2) and may be some prime lenses and Cokin Filter system.
My D90 also survive Mount KK right up to the Low's Peak :cool:.
Any DSLR camera you get you must have UV Filter for your lenses to protect the front lenses.

Mount KK is nothing la. Not even that cold...

I've operated my D90 in -25 deg C temperatures and it worked like a charm. What turned out to have trouble working in that temperature is me and my fingers. In about 20 seconds operating the camera and tripod, I felt my fingers were dropping off. But the cam worked perfectly.

shot at that kind of temperature at sunrise...
4303634393_135e3e5ff2_z.jpg
 

Mount KK is nothing la. Not even that cold...

I've operated my D90 in -25 deg C temperatures and it worked like a charm. What turned out to have trouble working in that temperature is me and my fingers. In about 20 seconds operating the camera and tripod, I felt my fingers were dropping off. But the cam worked perfectly.

shot at that kind of temperature at sunrise...
4303634393_135e3e5ff2_z.jpg

you mean you took off your gloves? risk frost bites! :nono:
 

you mean you took off your gloves? risk frost bites! :nono:

Yes I took off my gloves for that morning. Didn't get frost bite in the end. :bsmilie:
 

Back
Top