Who is qualified enough to give critic

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

I am making one assumption here, that this thread has a lot to do with norloke's "Yuki".

Where in that thread did you get the notion that he felt that his picture was great? See posts #115,128, 136, 170, 178, 264, 266, 273.

Basically in these various posts, norloke said that he wanted to express his ideas his way. In several posts he admitted to several problems he had.

U suddenly become historian...

actually, i'm still human, with a normal human brain, with normal human instinct... so a thread like this appear... how not to associate with that thread? maybe u might wanna explain to me y was it not associated instead...

besides the point, i dunno how come u can do search so fast with every post in mind... really take my hats off u... :thumbsup: but then again, i dun wanna argue with u, cos its tiring lah... going thru that 16 pages is hell... y not u answer my last question, at least still fresh in my mind...

 

[eikin]

U suddenly become historian...

actually, i'm still human, with a normal human brain, with normal human instinct... so a thread like this appear... how not to associate with that thread? maybe u might wanna explain to me y was it not associated instead...

besides the point, i dunno how come u can do search so fast with every post in mind... really take my hats off u... :thumbsup: but then again, i dun wanna argue with u, cos its tiring lah... going thru that 16 pages is hell... y not u answer my last question, at least still fresh in my mind...

forget it DCA, there's more to life than worthless sparring of words inside a virtual environment that seems bigger than life, isn't it?

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

forget it DCA, there's more to life than worthless sparring of words inside a virtual environment that seems bigger than life, isn't it?

yup yup... tats y i moving on... hehe... i see flame i run... me scared fire now... :bsmilie:

 

[student]

actually, i'm still human, with a normal human brain, with normal human instinct... so a thread like this appear... how not to associate with that thread? maybe u might wanna explain to me y was it not associated instead...

Of course it is associated. It is just a way of writing.

besides the point, i dunno how come u can do search so fast with every post in mind... really take my hats off u... :thumbsup: but then again, i dun wanna argue with u, cos its tiring lah... going thru that 16 pages is hell... y not u answer my last question, at least still fresh in my mind...

Did I dodge questions? No, because the answers were already given. Just that I do not like to give direct answers.

Why can I do search so "fast"? Actually not fast. But you have no idea what kind of training I had, the work I used to do, and am doing now.

 

[student]

yup yup... tats y i moving on... hehe... i see flame i run... me scared fire now... :bsmilie:

Don't worry!

The flames will NOT come anywhere near you!:bsmilie:

 

[eikin]

and since there are so much unhappiness over comments made over one another's works, why don't we ask the admin to put in black and white in the rules and regulations that NO COMMENTS NOR CRITIQUE IS ALLOWED inside CS and have the Critique Corner closed down. everyone will also only need to say the pictures are like that because that is what he/she wants, and since only the maker of the picture understands the way the pictures work, if a viewer likes it, a comment like 'nice' or 'i like' will be most appropriate, and if the viewer cannot understand nor appreciate the picture maker's artistic inclination, the viewer shall be asked to remain silent.

happy ending

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

Of course it is associated. It is just a way of writing.



Did I dodge questions? No, because the answers were already given. Just that I do not like to give direct answers.

Why can I so search so "fast"? Actually not fast. But you have no idea what kind of training I had, the work I used to do, and am doing now.

u confusing me again... oh well...

*can i move on* u won't tell me to move my si lang tao rite... :sweatsm:

 

[ortega]

wah!
you all,
not finished yet!!!???

yawn.......

never ending discussion

in the near future it will surface again and again
want to post must accept C&C

no matter if the C&C is good or not
it is up to you the poster to filtre the good from the bad

 

[arpinkor]

Aiyah, just send your critiques by PM to the poster can oredi. Case closed.

 

[eikin]

Aiyah, just send your critiques by PM to the poster can oredi. Case closed.

great idea :thumbsup:

so let's make CS a 'nice' place where 'i like' yah?

 

[student]

no matter if the C&C is good or not
it is up to you the poster to filtre the good from the bad

You are absolutely right!

Unfortunately, when the poster filtered (Selective) what he perceived to be useful or not, he was taken to task for being selective!

How?

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

great idea :thumbsup:

so let's make CS a 'nice' place where 'i like' yah?

i wan a 1000 PM box...

 

[ortega]

how about everyone stroke each other's egos


wow! that is a good shot :thumbsup:

or

wow! that is a good shot :thumbsd:

only the above 2 posts are allowed, everything else via PM

 

[eikin]

i wan a 1000 PM box...

you are just amazing, so hardworking of you :thumbsup:

 

[eikin]

how about everyone stroke each other's egos


wow! that is a good shot :thumbsup:

or

wow! that is a good shot :thumbsd:

only the above 2 posts are allowed, everything else via PM

what else can i say? :thumbsup:

 

[ortega]

You are absolutely right!

Unfortunately, when the poster filtered (Selective) what he perceived to be useful or not, he was taken to task for being selective!

How?

the TS did not reply to my posts, it is only the way he defended his shot with excuses that pissed everyone off and started a flame war

in his part 2 tread I even praised him and he still did not reply to me
I am so sad

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

the TS did not reply to my posts, it is only the way he defended his shot with excuses that pissed everyone off and started a flame war

in his part 2 tread I even praised him and he still did not reply to me
I am so sad

at least he is showing his selectiveness... :bsmilie:

 

[arpinkor]

i wan a 1000 PM box...

Yah, you need it for all the flame ..er... I mean fan mail :bsmilie:

how about everyone stroke each other's egos


wow! that is a good shot :thumbsup:

or

wow! that is a good shot :thumbsd:

only the above 2 posts are allowed, everything else via PM

Yah, critics must fill in the critique form one. Only multiple choice allowed, no free text one. :bsmilie:

 

[ortega]

actually any TS should read the C&C as the viewer took the time to look, think and post

and answer with a thanks

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

Yah, you need it for all the flame ..er... I mean fan mail :bsmilie:



Yah, critics must fill in the critique form one. Only multiple choice allowed, no free text one. :bsmilie:

got free 2B pencils bo? :devil: