OK Coming back on topic, ie commenting on photos which have been posted.
I'll be brutally honest. Photographers are a pretty egoistic bunch (and I base that observation on myself). And they know where to go to get what they want.
If you're fishing for compliments and ratings to puff up your ego, you go to photosig.
If you want honest, useful critiques and comments, you go to Lance Lee's forum, or maybe photo.net.
If you've got a banal picture to post, you do it (close your eyes, open your mouth, take your medicine, it's good for you) right here in clubsnap. OK maybe pbase as well. And photosig is very quickly filling up with lots of banal photos as well.
See, I would compliment a shot which I like.
I would critique a shot which had potential, but could be improved in my opinion.
I would want to learn from someone who shot something I found stunning, what the settings were, how it was done, or just get creative ideas.
But with a banal photo, I'm usually at a loss. There's really nothing constructive to say, except "Could you please take more interesting photos?" And you quickly find out that some people are pretty sensitive about "constructive criticism". So you just keep quiet lor.
I'll be brutally honest. Photographers are a pretty egoistic bunch (and I base that observation on myself). And they know where to go to get what they want.
If you're fishing for compliments and ratings to puff up your ego, you go to photosig.
If you want honest, useful critiques and comments, you go to Lance Lee's forum, or maybe photo.net.
If you've got a banal picture to post, you do it (close your eyes, open your mouth, take your medicine, it's good for you) right here in clubsnap. OK maybe pbase as well. And photosig is very quickly filling up with lots of banal photos as well.
See, I would compliment a shot which I like.
I would critique a shot which had potential, but could be improved in my opinion.
I would want to learn from someone who shot something I found stunning, what the settings were, how it was done, or just get creative ideas.
But with a banal photo, I'm usually at a loss. There's really nothing constructive to say, except "Could you please take more interesting photos?" And you quickly find out that some people are pretty sensitive about "constructive criticism". So you just keep quiet lor.