defense for pple sued by odex?

[shinken]

Another excuse is that you don't like Odex's dubbing. Odex does not own the rights to all anime. But that does not mean that one should d/l anime also. Learn to respect intellectual property.

You're absolutely right. But it's the court that should being issuing the fines, not Odex. It's the creators that should receive compensation, not Odex.

The fight is not about justifying wrong actions. Flouting the law means flouting the law. Illegal means illegal. But in this case, it is turning into an unethical money making opportunity.

I could start an Anti Piracy of Photography Association, then get licenses to distribute photographs for a couple of photographers, then threaten legal actions and out of court settlements to the entire online community that downloads photographs. Giving the excuse that I'm fighting piracy, and that I'm claiming for costs. That's profiteering. That's what people are voicing out against. Not making excuses for the wrong acts. Try to get that clear at least.

 

[furrycake]

Bu guan shi Toa Nee or Dao Ni...
As long as is Tua Nee... limpeh love Nee...:bsmilie:

go get a Nee du lah aiyo... :sweat:



digressed too much liao...... btw who in cs kena letters from odex ah ? :sweat:

 

[garou12]

You're absolutely right. But it's the court that should being issuing the fines, not Odex. It's the creators that should receive compensation, not Odex.

The fight is not about justifying wrong actions. Flouting the law means flouting the law. Illegal means illegal. But in this case, it is turning into an unethical money making opportunity.

I could start an Anti Piracy of Photography Association, then get licenses to distribute photographs for a couple of photographers, then threaten legal actions and out of court settlements to the entire online community that downloads photographs. Giving the excuse that I'm fighting piracy, and that I'm claiming for costs. That's profiteering. That's what people are voicing out against. Not making excuses for the wrong acts. Try to get that clear at least.

i think you should have posted this in the other thread you started. This one ot already.

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

if your friends really wanted to help you then they shouldn't have mentioned here that you have color blindness.

its a fact i can't change what... nothing to be ashamed of... correct?

 

[deadpixel]

you sure there'll be criminal record? record for the child or the parent?

That's the problem, not sure and thus fear of the unknown.

The court can hand down a suspended sentence. The kid might be put on probation and required to do community work. If at any point during his probation he commits the offense again ... BOOM!

_

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

go get a Nee du lah aiyo... :sweat:



digressed too much liao...... btw who in cs kena letters from odex ah ? :sweat:

i scared until never open letterbox since last monday...

 

[eikin]

You're absolutely right. But it's the court that should being issuing the fines, not Odex. It's the creators that should receive compensation, not Odex.

The fight is not about justifying wrong actions. Flouting the law means flouting the law. Illegal means illegal. But in this case, it is turning into an unethical money making opportunity.

I could start an Anti Piracy of Photography Association, then get licenses to distribute photographs for a couple of photographers, then threaten legal actions and out of court settlements to the entire online community that downloads photographs. Giving the excuse that I'm fighting piracy, and that I'm claiming for costs. That's profiteering. That's what people are voicing out against. Not making excuses for the wrong acts. Try to get that clear at least.

savior :lovegrin:

 

[eikin]

The court can hand down a suspended sentence. The kid might be put on probation and required to do community work. If at any point during his probation he commits the offense again ... BOOM!

_

the last time the kid who got warned for distributing MP3 online, was he put on probation? just quoting whatever's closest to the situation since there's no precedent :think:

 

[yqt]

eh, i din notice that, is garou12 hinting me for a date?:lovegrin: :lovegrin: :lovegrin:

Oi, you trying to go one big round and shoot me isit? I got wife and kids one OK, anyhow say, you want round 2 har. Quick, say sorry to uncle :angry:

 

[furrycake]

i scared until never open letterbox since last monday...

i personally dont think Odex has a case.. but he did sparkle off some fireworks... who is the OWNER of those anime? full stop.

anyway just go open letterbox lah, at most dio fined, thats how i see it :dunno:

 

[Cheesecake]

Damn, I thought it's some kind of food ;p

Anyway how does a xedoxised cheesecake taste like?

it tastes like S$5000/,

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

Oi, you trying to go one big round and shoot me isit? I got wife and kids one OK, anyhow say, you want round 2 har. Quick, say sorry to uncle :angry:

i din say u date me mah...

i thought garou trying to date me lah... so... :think:

 

[furrycake]

Oi, you trying to go one big round and shoot me isit? I got wife and kids one OK, anyhow say, you want round 2 har. Quick, say sorry to uncle :angry:

date only mah, go drink a cup or two tao huay chwee, okay wat :lovegrin:
unless you expect something when you date dca :sweatsm:

 

[eikin]

date only mah, go drink a cup or two tao huay chwee, okay wat :lovegrin:
unless you expect something when you date dca :sweatsm:

DCA is korean idol leh, you go date him wait you get electrocuted until you become dao huay :bsmilie:

 

[Del_CtrlnoAlt]

date only mah, go drink a cup or two tao huay chwee, okay wat :lovegrin:
unless you expect something when you date dca :sweatsm:

Girls can't resist me, Guys can't tahan me... :devil:

 

[yqt]

The court can hand down a suspended sentence. The kid might be put on probation and required to do community work. If at any point during his probation he commits the offense again ... BOOM!

_

Same thing applies. Would any parent want to risk that? If this is the sentence that Odex will use this as an example for the rest to see.

 

[furrycake]

DCA is korean idol leh, you go date him wait you get electrocuted until you become dao huay

:ipuke: saw him before so dont challenge me :nono:

Girls can't resist me, Guys can't tahan me... :devil:

:ipuke: im auntie, which category am i :devil:

 

[deadpixel]

the last time the kid who got warned for distributing MP3 online, was he put on probation? just quoting whatever's closest to the situation since there's no precedent :think:

I think he was.

But there was also the teen who illegally used his neighbour's WiFi, he was put on probation. Different crime, I know, but it does show that the courts are willing to be lenient to young offenders; but if I remember correctly for this case, his lawyers had to show that the kid was an Internet Gaming addict.

_

 

[deadpixel]

Same thing applies. Would any parent want to risk that? If this is the sentence that Odex will use this as an example for the rest to see.

Yep, yep.

I'm not sure about Singapore, but in some countries, like Canada, having a suspended sentence still means that you'll have a criminal record.

_

 

[eikin]

I think he was.

But there was also the teen who illegally used his neighbour's WiFi, he was put on probation. Different crime, I know, but it does show that the courts are willing to be lenient to young offenders; but if I remember correctly for this case, his lawyers had to show that the kid was an Internet Gaming addict.

_

either way, i think it's wrong for Xedo (hehehe, everyone loves the new term) to ''ask'' for such a high sum of compensation from the parents when even the court is not going to be so heavy handed on the kids.