The bigshot

[zaren]

haha ,,,,, you missed the major flaw, it was supposed to be a landscape shot, and he did it in a portrait :bsmilie::bsmilie::bsmilie:

a big problem was that they did not have an eminent landscape photographer as their guest judge for that episode. any one of the more prominent landscape photographers in CS would have done a better job with the critique and the judging IMHO.

once again....."TEA CUPS?????!!!!!!!" :bsmilie:

 

[nitewalk]

a big problem was that they did not have an eminent landscape photographer as their guest judge for that episode. any one of the more prominent landscape photographers in CS would have done a better job with the critique and the judging IMHO.

once again....."TEA CUPS?????!!!!!!!" :bsmilie:

But even so, wouldn't they have realised that the tea cups is out of theme? Maybe if it is very technical stuff they may not critique well, but surely they shd be able to spot something out of theme?

 

[zaren]

But even so, wouldn't they have realised that the tea cups is out of theme? Maybe if it is very technical stuff they may not critique well, but surely they shd be able to spot something out of theme?

It is not rocket science, all the viewers could spot it immediately. Even Caleb was convinced that his shot was way off, and fully expected to be booted out.

 

[Cheesecake]

But even so, wouldn't they have realised that the tea cups is out of theme? Maybe if it is very technical stuff they may not critique well, but surely they shd be able to spot something out of theme?

it is a controversial decision.


they keep him in so that more ppl n CSers will tune in and watch. :bsmilie:



CCC!!! controversy creates cash!!! :cheers:

 

[nitewalk]

it is a controversial decision.

they keep him in so that more ppl n CSers will tune in and watch. :bsmilie:

CCC!!! controversy creates cash!!! :cheers:

I thought so, I felt perhaps they wanted to create a controversy but doesn't seem to work.

 

[Cheesecake]

I thought so, I felt perhaps they wanted to create a controversy but doesn't seem to work.

the programme is fine, the show's alrite. could do with more than 30mins of airtime.

the judges, perhaps, need a reshuffle and maybe a brief introduction of the judges before the start of the 'judging' could help to inform the audiences of their credentials.

i would think that audiences these days are a lot more... particular and very much well informed. :bsmilie:

 

[nitewalk]

the programme is fine, the show's alrite. could do with more than 30mins of airtime.

the judges, perhaps, need a reshuffle and maybe a brief introduction of the judges before the start of the 'judging' could help to inform the audiences of their credentials.

i would think that audiences these days are a lot more... particular and very much well informed. :bsmilie:

Not easy to make such shows. If they make it too technical, people will be turned off. But I always find that to make them participate in themes of different genre, is asking more for a generalist than a specialist. After all one could be a great architectural or landscape shooter but totally clueless in portraits. Granted there are some who are genuinely talented, can shoot different genre still do well in what they don't specialise.

 

[wakaowalao]

Not easy to make such shows. If they make it too technical, people will be turned off. But I always find that to make them participate in themes of different genre, is asking more for a generalist than a specialist. After all one could be a great architectural or landscape shooter but totally clueless in portraits. Granted there are some who are genuinely talented, can shoot different genre still do well in what they don't specialise.

You are right, but a typical proficient photographer should always be able to apply all the basic "by default". Watching the last 3 episodes kinda shows them as nothing more than GWC/WWC, better off using a p&s or iPhones.

 

[zaren]

the programme is fine, the show's alrite. could do with more than 30mins of airtime.

the judges, perhaps, need a reshuffle and maybe a brief introduction of the judges before the start of the 'judging' could help to inform the audiences of their credentials.

i would think that audiences these days are a lot more... particular and very much well informed. :bsmilie:

there are plenty of excellent landscape photographers in singapore.
just invite one of them to be the guest judge for the Landscape Photography Theme.

 

[Rashkae]

there are plenty of excellent landscape photographers in singapore.
just invite one of them to be the guest judge for the Landscape Photography Theme.

Agreed. Just look for them in the trees.

 

[kei1309]

Agreed. Just look for them in the trees.

remember... they must be using a pentax K-5 and fully naked

 

[zaren]

remember... they must be using a pentax K-5 and fully naked

nikon preferred, for obvious reasons.

 

[kei1309]

nikon preferred, for obvious reasons.

i was referencing something that someone said :bsmilie:

 

[BTBFM2]

OUTSTANDING job by Caleb this wk!

I would say this is the best shot in this series, no doubt about it!
well done

 

[edutilos-]

OUTSTANDING job by Caleb this wk!

I would say this is the best shot in this series, no doubt about it!
well done

Are you from Brooks Institute?

:bsmilie:

 

[BTBFM2]

first time in this series that all judges are so unanimous in their view. All GOODs and no BUTs

 

[BTBFM2]

Are you from Brooks Institute?

:bsmilie:

no lah, from local university. LOL
just stating fact.
dont you agree?
can see that Tommy himself LOVE it too.:bsmilie:

 

[kei1309]

no lah, from local university. LOL
just stating fact.
dont you agree?
can see that Tommy himself LOVE it too.:bsmilie:

NPNT.

 

[BTBFM2]

NPNT.

WTF?................

 

[kei1309]

WTF?................

Pics or it didn't happen.