jim_mcgill
New Member
1234567
jim_mcgill said:Bridgerock said:Hi Jim,
Just check with you on telephoto lenses for S3IS. Previously got the 0.66x wide angle lens from you. Now I wonder if there is suitable telephoto lens for the S3IS. I heard of issues with the 2.2x (what is the actual issue?) but what about the 1.54x and the 1.85x? Are they suitable?
Hi Keck Kiong,
Many thanks for your queries!
Certainly there are some good models for your S3IS!
The issue with the 2.2x is actually a matter of magnification. When at telephoto mode, the highest is 26.4x. As you may know, the higher the magnification, the more the optics will be tested, probably to the extreme. Since the lens is basically of achromatic design, it may magnify the chromatic abberration or what is commonly known as colour fringing.
Also unless you have a pair of very steady hands, it should be tripod-mounted if you want to take pics at such a magnification so as to get steady and clear images.
You can look at the page below to assess for yourself if you are ok with this DCR-2020PRO lens. The pelican/egret pic looks very acceptable to me though the eagle pic might seem a bit blur, but then this might be due to hand movement of the shooter.
http://raynox.co.jp/comparison/digital/comp_pss2is.htm#dcr-2020pro
The DCR-1540PRO is only at 1.54x, so basically it can be used hand-held with a pair of steady hands. Also images can look pretty sharp due to the lower magnification compared to the DCR-2020PRO. Not to mention the cute and compact design.
The 1.85x model is not suitable with the S5/S3/S2 series as it's meant for digicams with optical zoom of 6x or lesser, like the G7.
So it can be pretty subjective. Some S3 users keep the 2020PRO while others prefer the 1540PRO. You decide!
By the way, 2020PRO still in stock, 1540PRO already sold out.
Cheers,
Jim, McGill.