Expose False Advertising and Broken Camera?


Status
Not open for further replies.
hi guys, i am in a bit of a conundrum here, and hope the more senior forumers can provide some guidance.

i accompanied a friend today to buy his first DSLR. he was on a pretty tight budget, so opted to go with a second hand piece to mess around with first. naturally, we trawled the buy/sell section for suitable deals and managed to find one. he arranged for a meet up, and today, we both went down to hopefully complete the deal.

unfortunately, the item was very falsely advertised. first off, the item condition was rated at 9. this was far from the case. the kit lens appeared to be rather banged up, with scuffs all over the barrel, smudges on the front element, and even a significant dent near the rim of the front element. the body itself didn't appear to be too well taken care of, but we did not feel that the looks (or lack thereof) were too much of a deal-breaker as long as the camera functioned properly. we realized almost immediately that we might have spoken too soon. while the camera could be switched on, the SDHC card slot's catch was broken, so a memory card could be inserted but would never stay in place. this obviously meant that shots could not be taken and saved.

we asked to see the warranty papers, thinking that maybe we could get it at a discounted price and then bring to nikon to have them service it under warranty. two unfilled warranty cards were offered, but no receipt. we asked for it, but when he could not provide one, he tried to subtly draw our attention back to the warranty cards. when we mentioned that these cards were useless without a receipt, that the camera is essentially not under warranty, he quickly relented.

lastly, and although this might seem trivial to most, the camera was advertised as belonging to a female user, but the person who turned up was a guy. i'm bringing this up because he appeared to have a pretty decent camera with him (some nikon with a battery grip, inside his "nikon professional" bag). as such, i would assume that he would possess at least a basic understanding of the nature of the item he is selling; falsely advertised condition, broken memory card catch rendering it unusable, not under warranty anymore.

right now, i'm worried that he might try to pass off this item to an unsuspecting beginner, but i'm unsure as to whether i should expose him. please advise.
 

Can you point out which buy/sell thread are you referring to for us to look further. Thank you.
 

Expose and request seller explain in open forum.
Maybe some misunderstanding of the rating system on the sellers part however the situation does stink of attempted scamming of a noob.
 

bro, that's the thing, i really want to, but i don't know if this would be considered a breach of ethics of sorts in this forum.

i realized that the item is now listed as sold. oh man, i hope the item hasn't already been offloaded to a clueless noob who is in for hell.
 

2 words: Caveat Emptor
 

It would be wrong not to expose the seller. You can help make BnS a better place.
 

Hmmm, this seller apparently has been doing quite a number of buys and sells on BnS. D80 (at least 2 units), 18-55mm D40.... Sounds like old bird to me. LOL.
 

precisely. based on the camera in his bag which i managed to sneak a peek of, and his history in the B&S section, i cannot bring myself to believe that this seller is completely unaware of things. :think:
 

PM sent inviting seller to thread.
 

i just received this PM from the seller.

"Hi there,

Firstly i seriously apologise about today incident. I was helping a fren of mine (Her) to sell her D40. I didnt see her condition and ask her to rate it and she gave me 9. I trusted her and posted the thread.

Today a guy meet u up on her be half because she is working she cant make it. I hope this matter rest between us because I dont wan my careless mistake end me up with a bad reputation in Clubsnap.

Please reply me if my apology is accepted.

Thank you so much for your time."
 

Hi people,

Firstly I would like to sincerely apologise to jonnodotsg, I was doing my friend a favour to sell her camera and I was stupid enough to rate it as 9 but didnt even actually see the actual condition. I claim it was a female user but a guy turn up because she was in a meeting and this guy friend helped her.

It is a total misunderstanding and my careless mistake wasted your precious time. I sincerely apologise and hope to close this matter peacefully.

Regards,
Careless guy
 

Hi people,

Firstly I would like to sincerely apologise to jonnodotsg, I was doing my friend a favour to sell her camera and I was stupid enough to rate it as 9 but didnt even actually see the actual condition. I claim it was a female user but a guy turn up because she was in a meeting and this guy friend helped her.

It is a total misunderstanding and my careless mistake wasted your precious time. I sincerely apologise and hope to close this matter peacefully.

Regards,
Careless guy


As a reminder to all forum users who use the Buy/Sell section to sell things to treat the rating system with respect. To grade something that is close to 3 with a 9 can result in not just serious misunderstanding, but you are wasting someone else's time. If this continues, the buy/sell section cannot continue to operate as no one else will believe what other forum users say there.

Rate the item according to the guidelines provided and look at the item personally before rating. You are responsible for the item if you list it, and if the item turns out to be otherwise, your reputation will go down with it.

I hope that this is made clear to all - integrity is key.
 

practise caution :)

tat girl in front of me,...some guyz rate her "stunning beauty", but i jus find her so-so...

beauty in the eye of the beholder
 

well as darren has said and another CS-er mentioned earlier

caveat emptor- let the buyer beware

of course it is unethical of him to do so

and now that we know, people will guard against him

thanks for sharing
 

poor buyer.....how am pm him/her how is the new D40?...
 

I don't quite buy the story.. but oh well..
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top