not spilling the beans or flaming but when G lenses are mounted the apertures will be opened to its largest for full aperture indexed metering but the moment you shoot it will close down to its smallest.
You would have noticed the camera's metered exposure is set for the smallest aperture and you have no control over its setting.
Have you seen the photos taken with them? or did you and your friend just try "blank" shots?
No issue with F5 & F6 though.