i think you are misunderstanding the use of the word "Public". in this case would mean "the rest of the world" (as opposed to keeping it as a private collection for the composer's personal use). I don't think that arguing over the technicality of a single word would work when you are being sued (regardless of whether its by COMPASS or the respective record label). my apologies if i have offended.
anyway, which are the hotels that have started enforcing this ? I would very much like to know.
Question: I get all my songs through a PAID website and the website is a legal website i.e. I bought those songs and music via internet. If I played those songs in weddings, am I violating the law? :dunno:
yes u are. Because the songs are for personal listening and not public broadcast. Actually all songs that are being played at weddings, functions etc are all chargeable. An authority called COMPASS collects the fees for music usage and then gives them to the relevant musicians. However common sense tells u there is no way they have enough manpower to go catch everyone.
COMPASS created a stir in recent years when they went to catch store owners playing CNY music in Malaysia.... sigh....
hmm.. it suddenly occur to me, what about those stores in the shopping center and the shops along the streets that are playing musics/songs in the store via their hi-fi/speakers? are they suppose pay for copyrights?
man, it is going to be so quiet everywhere...
I did this at the last wedding I covered. Not sure if it's perfectly legal but definitely won't try it ever again![]()
I have checked with one of the hotels on this. The reply from them is the couple needs to produce the original CD and they will get their AV guy to play the song during the screening of the soundless montage. No need to purchase any license as the hotel already has the license to broadcast music in the ballroom.