16 Conclusions On United 2 Liverpool 1
If you don't want to read about the (non) handshake, which is perfectly understandable, skip down to point four. Nick Miller tries to make some sense of that one...
curry sauce!
* It wasn't just a handshake, and anyone who says it is just naive. Both clubs have been talking this week about being on their best behaviour and diffusing tensions and blah, blah, blah, but a chap on Twitter called Matthew put it best: 'A handshake doesn't solve anything. However the refusal to do so is antagonistic.'
Nobody (aside from maybe Sepp Blatter) could sensibly argue that this ritual of the pre-match handshake means a great deal. In fact, this ritual that is supposed to show respect between the two clubs involved is causing more aggravation than it's worth, and we should ask the FA why, after they suspended it before the QPR v Chelsea game, they allowed it to happen this time.
Both men believed they had been wronged - Patrice Evra thought he was the subject of racial abuse, Luis Suarez thought Evra had (at best) exaggerated the claims and got him banned. One man chose to offer a small indication that this was behind everyone and move on, the other ignored him. Draw your own conclusions. And yes, Rio Ferdinand was also petty for not shaking Suarez's hand.
* You have to feel a little, little bit sorry for Kenny Dalglish. He told the Liverpool website this week: "People are already speculating on the pre-match ceremony, but from Luis's point of view we have spoken to him and I know he will shake the hand of Patrice Evra and the other Manchester United players before the game."
Talk about being stitched up by his man.
* Evra's celebrations at the final whistle were, if borne of frustration and a whole mixture of emotions, at best rather ill-advised (although at least they were in front of his own fans), but a quick word of praise for Phil Dowd, who apart from having a pretty decent game, stepped in to make sure nothing else serious came of it. A tiny, tiny bit of credit to Suarez as well for not responding.
* After spending the week telling everyone to calm down and not create trouble, the hyperbole from both managers after the final whistle was embarrassing. If you haven't already read their reaction, Dalglish said it was 'bang out of order' to blame Suarez for any trouble and tried to shift the responsibility to Sky Sports News, while Ferguson claimed Suarez shouldn't be allowed to play for Liverpool again. I rather hoped the end of the game would be the end of the issue, but alas not.
* Right, football, anyone? The first thing to say is that the first half was one of the more tedious 45 minutes the Premier League has produced this season. Whether it was nerves, whether everyone was distracted or whether it was just what happens in these games occasionally, both teams were disjointed and could barely string three passes together. Half-time was sweet, sweet relief.
* After the break it was only just better. As Dalglish said after the game, it was the timing of Wayne Rooney's two goals that killed Liverpool. A couple of strikes in quick succession prevented Liverpool from gathering themselves after half-time and play the containing game they wanted to. From that point they had to attack, but could not get out of their funk, even after the substitutions.
* Quite apart from any other questions, Suarez simply didn't look fit. One of his primary threats is his sharp, busy running and at stages he looked like he was running through glue. And since he hasn't played a full game since Boxing Day, it's hardly a surprise that he looked sluggish. Of course, 'manager playing best player in huge game' isn't usually a headline, but until he scored his opportunist's goal, he offered very little. One has to ask serious questions about why he played in this enormous game.
* Suarez was poor, but he wasn't helped by his teammates. For long spells he was isolated, with Liverpool's three-man midfield offering little or no support, leaving the Uruguayan to feed on scraps. Indeed, the average positions of Steven Gerrard, Jay Spearing and Jordan Henderson were all in their own half of the centre circle.
* It wasn't the only curious selection decision made by Dalglish. He made very clear in his pre-match press conference that he had is whole squad fit and available, so it was curious in the extreme not to pick Craig Bellamy, who has been their most threatening player in the last few weeks. Surely sticking Bellamy on the right wing, and telling him to spend the afternoon running at Evra, who quite apart from any other distracting issues, is not the player he was, would have been preferable. As it was, Dirk Kuyt offered little, while on the other wing Stewart Downing was utterly anonymous. And Andy Carroll might be rather aggrieved to miss out, given that this United defence has been bullied this season and he has finally started to show some form.
* You may all have your own times, but for me the 'Oh, Downing's playing, is he?' moment came after 43 minutes when he fouled Rafael.
* Having said that Carroll should perhaps have started, he looked back to his bad old ways when he did come on. At one point, he was beaten in the air by Rafael. That shouldn't happen.
* Looking at the teams before the game, playing Michael Carrick and Paul Scholes in midfield against Liverpool's three looked like a mistake, but as it turned out they controlled things nicely for Manchester United. Both were neat and precise with their passing (94% and 91% pass completion rates respectively), and didn't allow their rivals to impose themselves in the manner that they needed to. Both men have been criticised on this site before for assorted reasons, but they performed well on this occasion.
* Exactly what was Glen Johnson doing for United's first goal? Sure, Rooney was quick to dart in front of him to score, but the Liverpool right-back gave him far too much space and he was allowed a free shot on the edge of the six-yard box. Johnson's old problems with defending have been well-documented, but this game provided more evidence for those who believe he would be better as a right-midfielder. Indeed, he attacked reasonably effectively in the first-half, but his defending undermined his position.
* One potentially worrying thing for United. They were comfortably the better side, but that was in many ways because Liverpool were so bad. They should really have given their opponents a convincing beating, but were left hanging on rather at the end. Having said that, they're top of the league (at the time of writing), so should they be too bothered about how many they score?
* Nobody was surely silly enough to be surprised that Suarez and Evra were booed, but it's still bloody stupid. Sure, there might not be a much easier way of expressing one's displeasure, but those who boo at a football match just sound like kids. I haven't booed at a football game since I was about 13, because I'd feel like an idiot doing so . Sure, swear, shout, scream, but booing? Really? Is that the best you've got?
* Finally, before the game Greater Manchester Police confiscated all copies of United fanzine 'Red Issue' because of a cut-out Luis Suarez KKK hood that was in the new edition, planned to be on sale at the ground. Heavy-handed authoritarianism, or a sensible way of calming things down?
Nick Miller - follow him on Twitter, but be gentle