The facts speaks for itself.
It is tiring to follow this thread and replying to salvos and salvos from defensive followers of a person they assumed I am attacking. And not to mention the sarcasm and personal attacks I am deflecting from by replying to them. I am not attacking any person now. I am bringing to attention an important issue and hope that photographic forums in Singapore will not have repeat postings of photos like
http://forums.clubsnap.org/showpost.php?p=446538&postcount=8 or even dead/mutilated cats as Newman mentioned. I viewed that posting with dead cat before and it replused me immediately. Maybe that is why I decided to act on the recent photograph.
Let me tell you an account I personally went through. This is not a scenario.
Not long ago, I went with a group of photographers to an island for photoshooting. This group of girls and guys included some prominent photographers as well as newbies. On one morning, we are to trek to a jetty to catch a boat for a morning cruise to other islands. As we treked through the villages, one of us, (B) who is a very prominent local award winning photographer, soon felt the need to answer nature's call. There were the three of us guys in the front with the girls and other guys a good distance away and not visible to us. B soon relented and went to do his business behind a tree and bushes while my playful friend and mischevious me, joked and schemed about capturing that moment of B in front of bushes doing his business to poke fun on B later.
As B was answering nature's call, I quickly took my DSLR to take a few snaps of B. It was a side view with clear identification of B and a stream of liquid jetting out, without sight of any genitalia though. B realised that he was being shot but he cannot do anything as he was in the middle of business.
When B finished, my friend and I taunted B that we have a shot of a fireman fighting fire in the forest to show the rest. B show some embarrassment and just kept quiet. He did not go after me or my friend. We continued to trek to the jetty.
On reaching the jetty, we rested in a snack shop for the rest to reach. As the group fully reassembled, I started to review the photos taken. As I went through the shots, I asked myself whether I really wanted to show this around? What good does it do to anybody? Does it make me a better candid shot photographer? Does it embarrass B unneccessarily? I am not a small kid now and my actions could mean many consequences; dimensions of proper behavior, moral, conscience, friendship and even legal.
So I decided that these shots of B in that moment by me, despite being taken in clean fun, is not proper in the first place. At that moment, I went to B and showed him the photos in the DSLR. And I told him that I am deleting these photos and no one will see them ever. And I proceeded to delete the photos one by one before him.
The point I want to make is that if the photo you have taken of the subject could potentially cause any discomfort, embarrassment or ill feeling to the subject, whether you know him/her or not. Then pls do not take the photo. If you insist to capture that photo, pls do not ever post or publish it for the world to see.
I am signing off now.
I wanted to sign off earlier but thought against that as this matter weighs enough importance to get it into our consciousness so that it is never repeated. If it is repeated, at least the poll shows that there should be enough people with common sense to tell the poster off!
At this moment, here is the result of the poll.
Is it okay to post/publish unflattering photos of strangers without their permission?
63 people voted as at 23-10-2003 02:30 PM
Yes [ 17 ] 26.98%
No [ 46 ] * 73.02%
The poll speaks for what is the right thing to do.