my personal opinions:
-its very unfair to compare those 2 images. 1 is ISO 800 and the other is ISO 320. if u wanna compare, use the same exposure settings.
- personally, i prefer high iso performance to IS/VR/AS. under some situations (for e.g. celebrities performance, sports, etc...), the stabilization would not help u get a sharp image as u would need a high shutter speed if lighting is insufficient.
- to overcome my own handshakes, i can always bring a monopod to stabilize the camera, no doubt less convinient. to each his own
his money, his reasoning, his camera...he already bought the camera, whaddya want him to say?
likewise i sold my S3IS after trying borrowing my friends F30 for a wk. Now I know what noise is...
ut ur right abt apple to apple comparison, u need to use same ISO. Then again ,many digicam review sites showing the obvious difference.