Need advice: Kodak DCS 645 Pro back vs. DSLR


Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a chance to get an OLDER Kodak 16mp back complete with body and 3 lenses to swap with my 50D and all my lenses.

Assuming everything is equal subject, lighting, etc... Question is do I lose on image quality? I am tempted to get the MF due to my percieved expectation of better IQ, however, the back is at least 4 years old at best.
 

i wouldn't do it. that back was never fantastic, even when it was one of the only ones of its kind. the sensor is the same size as a 35mm piece of film if you include the perforation holes (cut in a square). quite a bit bigger than a 50d's sensor and bigger than a FF dslr, but not that much bigger.

i am making an assumption that the body you would get is the Mamiya 645afd with a replaced focus screen with square crop marks. when i shoot MF, 6x6 is my favourite format, however shooting a square crop in a 6x4.5 viewfinder will be really odd and you will make quite a few framing mistakes. this back also does a weird 4x5 crop, which is pointless to use. the body does not auto focus very well. i can't remember on the original 645afd if it has 1 or 3 auto-focus points. i currently have the afdiii which only has 3 points, and i always focus manually. i'm sure it will come with the 80mm 2.8, which isn't a bad lens. i'm taking a punt that you'll also get the 55mm 2.8 and the 150mm 3.5, which are also nice lenses.

if you are getting it with the contax body, i can't comment as i never shot it on that body.

the dcs 645 back is *really* slow. take a picture, wait for it to write. a couple of seconds later, take another photo. if you want to see the image on the screen, then wait for it to be processed. while this is fine if you're using it in a studio or doing portraits, compared to the 50d, you will find it frustrating.

the good thing the back has going for it is it's daylight IQ. shadow detail and colour are fantastic - especially for portraits. compared to other digital backs, the high-iso noise is pretty minimal, provided you slightly over-expose your images on iso 200 and above (it only goes to iso 400...).

again i wouldn't trade. if anything i'd be saving my coins to get a full frame modern dslr instead of something that uses 8 year old sensor and processing technology. any difference in IQ can easily be made up for by investing time in your shot compose properly, expose to the right, consider your horizon, check your backgrounds, and bracket if necessary.
 

Well say :thumbsup:
 

I have both the 645AFD+DCS Pro and the 40D, and I use them for different occasions. If I have lots of time to compose and I can control the environment/subject, I will choose the 645. However, if I need a general purpose camera, I prefer the 40D.

Another thing about the DCS Pro is that it heats up pretty fast, especially if you are shooting under the sun. You will have to shut down the DB and wait for it to cool down - which can seem like eternity when you have the subject ready in front of you. Forget long exposures - after 3 or 4 shots the DB will be so hot you have to let it cool off for 10 mins before resuming.

On the other hand, if I need saturated colors, the DCS Pro is better than my 40D, even after PS my 40D shots.

I love them both. But if I have to choose only one, then I will stick with my 40D.
 

Last edited:
I had the Kodak Proback before moving to the Leaf 65

cons
1) heats up pretty fast. If you are shooting at a high rate, at one point you'll have to stop for the camera to cool down.
2) Megapixels by today's standard is not that high

pros
1) the colors direct from it is one of the best I've ever seen. It is able to render what I call the "equatorial blue" into a "temperate warm". Ever envy the warm colors you get when you take photos overseas ? the Kodak can do it for you even here in Singapore.
 

thanks for the advise... sticking with the 50d for now... and yeah the colors was the single most driver for me looking at the back... appreciate the points of views.

Cheers,

Tory
 

Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top