Hi bigdaystudio. Not sure how you are viewing the footage (e.g. eyes open or closed or what

) but if you look at the still below, hopefully you can see the artifacts around the guitarist's white T-shirt and on the neck of the guitar. This shouldn't happen with progressive footage. Most likely FCP has interpreted the clip as interlaced and then combined the wrong field pairs during rendering.
But I do agree with you that the shots are good.
http://www.jaegersing.com/HobbesIL.jpg