Problem solved.
I discovered the vignetting was somehow aggravated by the 12538 hood (I've been using this whilst waiting for the 12526 hood from BHphoto).
Wearing the 12526 hood, the vignetting is much smoother and less pronounced at F1.4. Almost cannot see.
I did not know hood can cause vignette
Glad that you solve your puzzle...every focal length has different fields of view to go with the right hood
12538 hood, although can be mount on a E39 filter lens, it is designed for 50mm f2 Summicron V3 lens, the field of view is much narrower than 35mm
12526 rectangular hood (small and neat) is originally designed for 35mm f2 Summicron ASPH, the fieid of view is designed for 35mm therefore, minimal vignetting due to hood, however this is meant for f2
The correct Leica designed hood for 35mm f1.4 pre-ASPH Summilux should be used are:
OLLUX 12522 (but too rare and expensive), for mounting on steel rim lux
12504 (Series VII filter)
These hoods opening are much wider as compared to 12526 or 12538...therefore no vignetting due to hood opening...a general rule, beside the physical mount, you can use a faster lens mount of the same field of view on slower lens without causing any vignetting.
Since you brought out the topic of 35mm hood...just to share some information on the vast variety of Leica 35mm hoods:
FIKUS - Clamp-on type, 35/f3.5 Elmar LTM
FLQOO - Clamp-on type, 35/f3.5 Elmar LTM
FOOKH - Clamp-on type, 35/f3.5 Summaron LTM V1
ITDOO - E39, round clip on type, 35/f3.5 Summaron LTM V2
IROOA - E39, round clip on type, 35/f2 Summicron V1, 35/f2.8 Summaron, 35/f3.5 Summaron
12459 - E39, round clip on type, 35/F2.5 Summarit
12585 - E39, round clip on type, 35/f2 Summicron V2/3
12585H - E39, round clip on type, 35/f2 Summicron V2/3
12504 - E39, round clip on type, Series VII filter, 35/f1.4
12524 - E39, rectangular clip on type, 35/f2 version 4
12526 - E39, rectangular clip on type, 35/f2 ASPH
12588 - E46, rectangular clip on type, 35/f1.4 ASPHERICAL (AA)
12589 - E46, rectangular clip on type, 35/f1.4 ASPH I
XXXXX - E46, rectangular metal hood, 35/f1.4 ASPH II (new FLE)
Bro Hacker, what is the order number for the hood of new 35 Lux?
