HD dvd cannot be read on my dvd player


yymun

New Member
Hi, i own a canon legria HF 200. Using given editing software by canon, Pixela (imagemixer3 SE).

After i transfer the footage to my pc and burn it to HD dvd (only max 18fps). My orginal footage is recorded in 24fps. When play it in my dvd player samsung & LG. It cannot be read! I call up tech help from canon, they said it only convert to AVCHD format.
Do anyone here use the same software to burn their video and can be read on their player? Or i should install another software to burn my video to HD dvd with 24fps?

Thank you:)
 

Hi,

DVD player only plays SD video i.e. Mpeg2 video in PAL(720x576) or NTSC.
Your HD video is not a DVD standard.
 

Sorry i am abit confuse. So those hollywood video that i purchase at dvd shop that play very clear moives are not HD standard but SD standard?
 

Yes. DVD are SD and not HD. HD is 720P and above while DVD are around 480P.
 

Hi,

Movies in DVD is SD. Movies in Blu-ray disc is HD.

My humble suggestion to you is go and buy a cheap media player in Sim Lim.
These players can play most SD and HD video formats. Just plug in your Hard disk or
memory cards with video files and it'll play.
 

Thank you very much for the info.

If the hollywood dvd that i bought is SD dvd, but the picture is so clear, unlike the dvd that i burn using LG dvd recorder is so grainly. My org footage is using 24 fps. Is there something wrong with my recorder? Is there any way that i can attent that clear picture for my holiday movies?

Option 1: transfer all my footage into a harddisk and using a media player direct link to HD tv to watch it.

Option 2: transfer all footage into a harddisk, buy a good editing software and blue ray writer to burn a HD dvd.

Can i to said the above option is correct?
 

Are you shooting your video in Auto mode?

You're using consumer equipment to make your holiday/home movies.
Whatever option you choose, your video will not even come close to Hollywood dvd.


Cheers!
 

Hi, i am using a full HD videocam, canon legria HF 200. So am i correct to said, no matter what brand consumer videocam w or w/o HD capability. The end result of burn a SD dvd will be same (grainly). never able to achieve those nice and smooth picture. :dunno:
 

Hi, i wonder is there any company does video editing course for beginner?
 

I believe consumer grade videocam, even full HD, when it is stored, the resulting video already go through on level of lossy compression, so some details are already lost.
The bitrate of the video might not be as high as well.
The software u use to re-encode might not be as good as well.
The optics of the consumer videocam are probably way inferior to those used by film studios.
 

bro, no need study video course lah...rather you spent your money to purchase video accessories for better videography.
Internet nowadays is full with these videos for learning about video thing, just go you tube and you can find a lot.
Go pick up the basic first, and if you have further questions, just post in CS forum, guys here are very friendly to help.
Make sure you google through all answers until you really don't know then ask.
Studying a course only last for few hours, but Internet searching is forever.
 

Last edited:
.
Hi yymun,

Pino1969 is correct. You need not go to a video course.
The money could be spent on buying better equipment.
And there are tonnes of materials on the internet that can be used to study from.
One just need to choose the ones that suits oneself.

However, if you are more comfortable learning the traditional way
in a classroom environment and don't mind spending some money,
try Googleing "Video Editing Course Singapore".
There are some links you may want to look at.

Good Luck :)
.
.
 

thank you very much for the info:)
 

Hi, i am using a full HD videocam, canon legria HF 200. So am i correct to said, no matter what brand consumer videocam w or w/o HD capability. The end result of burn a SD dvd will be same (grainly). never able to achieve those nice and smooth picture. :dunno:

For own personal usage should be OK but not for freelance work.

BTW, you can just render the footage as HD and watch in your computer, why DVD? If you want to play on your HD LCD then just buy a player that support thumbdrive or external harddisk and plug it in to play.

As for good DVD result that will depend on the software and settings you used to render the MPEG footage.
 

For own personal usage should be OK but not for freelance work.

BTW, you can just render the footage as HD and watch in your computer, why DVD? If you want to play on your HD LCD then just buy a player that support thumbdrive or external harddisk and plug it in to play.

As for good DVD result that will depend on the software and settings you used to render the MPEG footage.

Actually i would 3 backup copies of my video, pc hstddisk, extenal harddisk & dvd
 

HD-DVD is a format in rival with blu-ray, primarily promoted by Toshiba. But blu-ray won the war and Toshiba discontinued it.

You will need a (discontinued) HD-DVD player to playback HD-DVD.
 

Study from the right materials. Stop studying the wrong information and pass the CPA Examination the first time. Get review materials, flashcards, notes and cpa exam study materials.This link http://www.cpaarmy.com
 

Warrenmsayre said:
Study from the right materials. Stop studying the wrong information and pass the CPA Examination the first time. Get review materials, flashcards, notes and cpa exam study materials.This link http://www.cpaarmy.com

Bro u sure coming to the right thread? Lol
 

Hi yymun bro,

Looks like you are quite passionate about videography and filming too. =)

Just share with you some tips and tricks i've learnt along the way. Actually is nothing much, but hope it gives you a better insight to hd video workflows.

For personal, travel or for fun, a handycam is adequate, even iphone does a great job for this kind of videos too. But for work, weddings, commercial purposes, you need a professional grade camcorder. This is the same reason why ppl use dslr for commercial photo shoots.

The main difference in Consumer camcorders and professional camcorders are the sensor sizes and the bit rate it records in. Tape camcorders usually uses ccd sensors. These are the analog type of sensors, for digital camcorders, they are equipped with cmos sensors, which are also known as digital sensors. Both sets of sensors comes in various sizes. For entry to mid level dv and hdv camcorders, they possess 3CCD 1/3" sensors, for beta comcorders which are used in tv broadcast camcorders, they possess 3CCD 2/3" sensors. For film camaras used fir movie production they use film sensors equivalent to 35mm film size, which explains why film always have shallower depth of field and nicer colors than camcorders. For digital camcorders, they come with 1/3",1/2",2/3". and those large format sensors found in 5dmk2, red one etc, which are close or equivalent to 35mm film size.

Basically, the larger the sensor the cleaner your video quality will be. Smaller sensors usually will generate noise during low exposure shooting due to the increase in gain or iso value which subsequently leads to sensor overheating. Sensor heating ia the cuz of the graininess or noise you see in your videos.

Alot of ppl are wondering why dslrs like 5dmk2 etc are able to capture videos at such sharp and clean and filmic quality, even better than beta camcorders. That is because ppl always overlook at the amount of megapixels it can record. 5dmk2 records at 21.1 megapixels. Digital cams like red one shoots at even higher megapixels. Try shooting and comparing footages shot with 5dmk2 and your legria which both can shoot in 24fps prgressively. Push both cams to the max settings, you will see the difference. And not forgetting 5dmk2 uses full frame 35mm equivalent sized sensors, giving it more filmic look and colors plus shallow filmic depth of field.

Bit rate wise, honestly i do not know whether camcorder records to tapes with any amount of bit rate or not. But when it comes to digital workflows, bit rates are heavily involved. 5dmk2 records at a bit rate of abt 40mbps. With firmware hacks, it can record at 100mbps! The higher the bit rate, the better quality your videos are. Legria i m not sure, maybe 12 at the max? You can record at higher bitrates and render out to a lower bit rate without explicit drop in video quality, but you cant do the reverse.

Post production wise, of course there are many 3rd party plugins out there to touch up on all these, but trust me, it will just make your videos look "artificial" which is something you do not wish to achieve at the end of the day.

As for editing, if u r really into videography, perhaps you might want to try your hands on apple final cut or adobe premiere pro. Of course there are other big names like avid, ulead etc, but adobe and apple are the more commonly used and user friendly ones.

Hope thesr infos helps! =)

Oh yes, hd-dvd format is not ur regular Dvd format, thus it cant be played on ur dvd player. Simple as that.
 

Last edited:
Back
Top